Monday, January 28, 2013

A University without Faculty: The Demise of the University of Phoenix and the Rise of the MOOCs


The University of Phoenix is now the largest university in America, but this may soon change. This mostly online institution is facing an accreditation sanction, which could force it to lose its Pell Grants, student loans, and other federal subsidies. Not only is the stock price taking a major beating, but massive layoffs are underway.

Although we should not take enjoyment in other people’s job losses, it is important to focus on what happens when higher education is taken over by a soulless corporation. As the founder of the university has become a billionaire and has just received a $5 million retirement package, the school is shedding many of its on-the-ground employees. Like many other for-profit schools, the U. of Phoenix receives most of its funding from public monies, and then uses these funds to enrich administrators and shareholders and hire an army of marketers and recruiters in order to turn mostly under-represented minority students into unemployed debt slaves, and they do this by hiring all of their faculty off of the tenure system. In many ways, this school represents the extreme logic of the online education movement: eliminate tenure for the faculty, develop questionable distance education, cater to private corporations, and make students suffer with high debt levels and bogus degrees (actually very few students ever get their degrees, and very few get their promised jobs).

While online course providers like Coursera and Udacity appear to represent a much more progressive version of this high-tech education promotion, let us look at some of the statements that are coming out of the mouths of these not-for-profit, profit-seeking marketers. Here is Sebastian Thrun, founder of Udacity, from the UCLA forum (these quotes come from the rush transcript on Remaking the University): “Students rarely learn listening . . . or they never learn by listening. The challenge for us is to take this new medium and really bring it to a mode where students do something and learn by doing. And if you look at the broad spectrum of online technology with what happens. It doesn’t really take long time to point to video games. And most of us look down on video games. We’ve also played them. I know there are people in this room who play angry birds. Some people do. Some people don’t admit it. Angry birds is an wonderful learning environment because you get drawn in, you solve the physics problems but the big problem is that it stops at angry birds . . . if the angry birds was good enough to get into the masters students in physics. It would be an amazing experience and you could do this at scale.” The point I want to stress here is the claim that students never learn from listening. Following this logic, most of current education is simply useless, and we should just have students take out their smart phones and play Angry Birds all day.

During Thrun’s presentation at UCLA, this downgrading of traditional learning environments was connected to a downsizing of the faculty: “As we know that higher education is moving at a slower pace compared to the industry moves. We have been funded by a whole bunch of corporations that make the classes with us and there’s a number of classes launching soon on topics to be not covered in academia. If you look at the way the technology turns over, it will be 5-10 years in computer science [and] if you look at the way colleges turn over, it’s much more difficult because [with] tenure they are gonna be with us for 30 years so the national turnover rate for colleges is about 30 years. Industries it’s like 5-10 years. So there’s a disconnect between how the world changes and how colleges are able to keep up. Therefore in computer science it would be hard to find courses that teach technologies that are useful today such as IOS and all the wonderful things that they do. So the industries jumped in and funded us to build these classes.” According to this logic, since tenure requires a thirty-year commitment to the faculty, and industry and technology change at a much faster rate, we need to get rid of the secure faculty and replace them with student mentors and the latest technology.

Thrun’s argument fails to recognize that faculty also develop and change, and most faculty, including his own wife, now teach without tenure. His point of view also pushes the idea that technological change is always for the better, and even if it is not good, there is no way to resist it. As I have previously argued, we need to compare online courses to our best courses and not our worst, and we have to defend and define quality education and push for more funds to be spent on small, interactive classes. However, Thrun and other MOOC celebrators appear to have a disdain for their own teaching: “But in the existing classes, the level of services are often not that great. . . .I talked to numerous instructors and you divide the time the communal time and the personal time you give back to the students in terms of advising and grading . . . you can be lucky as a student for 3 credits class to get 3 hours of personal time. Many people laugh and many say I spend 10 min/student per class and the rest I give to my TAs. Charging $1,000-$4,000 for that to me is gonna be a question going forward.” Although I have often questioned what students are actually paying for in higher education, what Thrun is really questioning is the validity and value of large, impersonal lecture classes, and on this point, we are in agreement; still the question that remains is if large online courses can really provide the quality education they advertise.

At the last Regents meeting, many of these themes were continued as three computer science professors attempted to convince the UC system that online courses would make higher education “better, faster, and cheaper.” In her presentation for Coursera, Daphne Koller insisted that since students now have a very short attention span, the classic lecture has to be broken up into a series of short videos followed by an interactive question and answer system. She argued that this method paradoxically makes mass education personalized as it pushes students to constantly learn and be tested on material before they advance.

Like the other online course providers, in order to differentiate her “product” from the “traditional” model of education, Koller had to constantly put down the current way we educate students. Thus, she derided the “sage on the stage” and the inability of most students to ask questions in their large lecture classes. She also bemoaned the fact that no one wants to read students’ tests with identical questions and answers, and so the whole grading process can be given to computers and fellow students. Once again, this argument not only degrades the value and expertise of faculty, but it also treats students as if they need to be reimagined as programmable machines and free laborers. Yes, let’s have the students’ grade each other’s paper, and while they pay for their education, let us train them to work for free.

Another alarming aspect of the rhetoric of these providers is their constant reference to experimenting on students as they attempt to increase access to higher education. The idea presented at the Regents meeting is that since so many under-represented students cannot find places in the UC system, these students from underfunded high schools should be given an online alternative. Some have called this the Digital Jim Crow because wealthy students will still have access to traditional higher education, while the nonwealthy, under-represented minority students will be sent to an inferior online system. Of course this new form of educational segregation is being pushed under the progressive banner of expanding access.

79 comments:

  1. Wow, lots to think about.
    1. Looked up graduation rates from U.Phoenix. Wikipedia, citing 2007 and 2010 articles, says 16% vs. 55% according to Dept. of Ed. standards (I didn't look who computed on what data), but that UPh says since it has non-traditional students, grad rate actually 59% according to different standards (6 year window?). Is there a good study of this out there?

    2. Great point that online is being compared to large lectures, not small interactive seminars. Maybe indeed many large lectures could be done better online--but couldn't they be done even better than that as smaller lectures or seminars? If so in which cases? (Bob's point about Computer Science is well taken--we humanists may assume this for things like basic math as well.) If not, in which cases? Latter would be the place to put $ for online development.

    3. Leads to point made at end re: digital Jim Crow. Implicitly this recognizes that personal attention is better, at least for some learners. From what I've seen of research, it is precisely non-experienced learners (those who don't have good learning skills from home) who would benefit far more from the modeling and attention in personal instruction, and conversely do least well in the self-run online environment.

    ReplyDelete
  2. "University of Phoenix’s degree graduation rate is assessed by the federal government’s Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS). The University modified graduation rate, which takes into account the entire University student body, is defined as the percentage of students who completed at least three credits and went on to be degree-complete within 150 percent of normal degree completion time. Data are collected on the number of students entering the institution as degree-seeking students in a particular cohort year.

    University of Phoenix’s modified graduation rates for associate degrees reported in 2011 were 34 percent for those graduating within three years and 36 percent within four years, up from 32 percent and 35 percent, respectively, reported in 2010. Bachelor’s degree modified graduation rates declined from the 2010 Academic Annual Report to 31 percent for students who graduate within six years and 33 within eight years, both down by 3 percentage points in 2011." http://www.phoenix.edu/news/releases/2012/02/university-of-phoenix-releases-2011-academic-annual-report.html
    I bet they inflate these numbers somehow.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The promoters of this drive talk of access and affordability. Although I doubt that online classes actually are less expensive, I think the promoters believe they are. However, I assume there are no plans to lower UC tuition once the new wave of classes is up and running. So they see less cost at the same price. Who will get the profit? Probably not the university. My guess is that the economics of this drive favor third party vendors (who can move as fast as "the industry").

    Bob: I disagree with the blanket attack on online teaching. But the specific economics of this drive are very bad. The burden should be on the promoters to show how their version of online education will not result in private enrichment at public cost and student debt.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ada beberapa pengecualian untuk aturan ini. Jika saya di pertandingan persahabatan pokerbintang.com, jika saya di pertandingan duniatangkas.com kandang, atau bahkan jika saya dalam suasana hati yang santai dan bermain supertangkas.com dengan orang lain yang juga ada untuk "bersenang-senang" tidak "bisnis", maka saya mungkin menunjukkan beberapa ibcbetkita.net lebih tangan dari saya biasanya. ratupoker

      Delete
  4. NICE INFORMATION!!! Very creative work you have done, i like your post very much. Thanks for sharing !!
    Top PGDM Colleges in Pune
    PGDM Institutes in Pune

    ReplyDelete
  5. The fact is that at this point UoP has a bad industry reputation. Whether they have fixed the problem or not, you may be affected when you present your UoP certificate to a knowledgeable hiring manager.

    I reached this forum because I am in my second class for an MBA program at UoP, and already feeling that their quality of instruction is wanting. I obtained a bachelors degree from a traditional university, so I know what quality education is all about.

    Read about DOD renews contracts with four schools, drops University of Phoenix

    ReplyDelete
  6. Fabulous post. Thanks a ton for sharing your knowledge! It is great to see that some people still put in an effort into managing their websites. I'll be sure to check back again real soon.www.mycollegeplacement.com |

    www.getcalgaryhealthy.com |

    www.harveycedarsfitness.com |

    www.healthybeingmovie.com |

    www.herbalhealthhouse.com |

    www.easyhomeloansinc.com |

    www.glasshousecontemporary.com |

    www.holidayhomesturksandcaicos.com |

    www.homelandsecurityproductsllc.com |

    www.homelandsecurityspending.com |

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thanks a ton for sharing your knowledge! It is great to see that some people still put in an effort into managing their websites. I'll be sure to check back again real soon.www.allinfo4business.com |

    www.ferrarifashionstore.com |

    www.strengthyourrunning.com |

    www.houseimprovement4sure.com |

    www.granitestatesouth.com |

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thanks a ton for sharing your knowledge! It is great to see that some people still put in an effort into managing their websites. I'll be sure to check back again real soon.www.onlinesignsupplies.co.uk |

    www.tartanarmymessageboard.co.uk |

    www.mikestoanelighting.co.uk |

    www.workplace-wellness.co.uk |

    www.thumbswood.co.uk |

    www.oldfieldrealty.co.uk |

    www.utilitysearches.co.uk |

    www.bizzybooker.co.uk |

    www.restaurantrecruit.co.uk |

    www.vetequip.co.uk |

    ReplyDelete
  9. I think each one is obtaining additional from this website, and your views are enjoyable in favor of new folks.USB Low cost Ibeacons

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thanks for the unmatchable diary.it was rale useful for me.navigator sharing specified ideas in the instant as symptomless.srirambusinessschool.org |

    probusiness4u.org |

    bpl-business.org |

    bonnerbusinesscenter.org |

    businesstravelstjob.org |

    businessaffaires.org |

    newbusinessmodels.org |

    business-rating.org |

    thebusinessfinder.org |

    plumlivinghealth.org |

    ReplyDelete
  11. Not many providers experiment on the students, they naturally try to increase help them access the higher education.. and this will eventually lead to a better future. FIN 370 Final Exam

    ReplyDelete
  12. Comment moderation has been enabled. All comments must be approved by the blog author. www.plaket.biz.tr

    ReplyDelete
  13. Hal ini penting juga agen ibcbet , bahwa Anda menggunakan kata kunci agen sbobet yang paling pencari akan ibcbet menggunakan ketika mencari untuk jenis produk bola tangkas atau jasa. Ada beberapa generator kata kunci agen bola tangkas gratis yang tersedia secara online tangkas online yang tidak hanya memberikan beberapa kata kunci tangkas online untuk jenis bisnis Anda tangkas online indonesia, tetapi peringkat agen bola tangkas mereka dengan seberapa sering orang menggunakannya poker online ketika mencari jenis bisnis agen poker atau produk. Sebagai contoh, pencarian dewa poker cepat untuk "rumah gratis berbasis agen sbobet Generator kata kunci bisnis" mengungkapkan bahwa agen bola indonesia "bisnis berbasis rumah" kata kunci agen sbobet jauh dan menjadi agen bola tangkas pilihan utama. Namun, "berbasis agen bola terpercaya rumah peluang bisnis"

    ReplyDelete
  14. You can consider to practice SEO Costa Rica to obtain better position on the webrank. I have never read more interesting articles than yours before. You make me so easy to understand.

    ReplyDelete
  15. تابعي موقع باتيه وانتريه وتميزي في اعداد طريقة عمل الكشري المصري بكل احتراف ومهارة وسرعة في الاعداد والحصول على اروع طبق كشري ينال اعجاب الجميع ويبهر الجميع تابعي الطريقة عبر الرابط المباشر
    http://www.pntre.com/how-aml-egyptian-kosheri/

    ReplyDelete
  16. خصومات على جميع قطع الغيار المقدمه من خلال مركز صيانة كلفينيتور المعتمدة فى جميع محافظات مصر للمزيد من المعلومات تابعونا على الفور
    http://www.maintenanceg.com/Kelvinator-Center-Agent.html

    ReplyDelete
  17. اقل التكاليف مع مركز صيانة يونيون اير بصيانة بقطع غيار اصلية ..
    لتتواصل عبر الموقع الالكتروني :
    http://unionairemaintenance.com/

    ReplyDelete
  18. يمكنك الان مع افضل مركز لتدريس معادلة كلية هندسة باقل الاسعار واعلى الخدمات المقدمة للطالب .. للاستفسار يمكنك الاتصال على الارقام التالية :
    01093189974 — 01118585670

    للتواصل عبر الموقع الالكتروني

    http://www.معادلة-كلية-هندسة.com/

    ReplyDelete
  19. اقل الاسعار من مركز صيانة كلفينيتور
    مع افضل خدمة لما لدينا حملات صيانة في جميع انحاء الجمهورية باقل التكاليف ..

    ReplyDelete
  20. اقل الاسعار واعلى الخدمات مع افضل التصاميم المميزة من ديكورات شعبية باقل التكاليف .. للاستفسار يمكنك الاتصال على الرقم التالي :
    0501401148

    للتواصل عبر الموقع الالكتروني :

    http://mazallat.com/majalis-Heritage-decor-popular.html

    ReplyDelete
  21. افضل شركة نقل عفش بجدة باقل الاسعار واعلى الخدمات لما لدينا مجموعة مميزة

    ReplyDelete
  22. شركة العنود لديها فريق متميز يقوم بكافه اعمال التنظيف للسيراميك وارضيات الرخام بشقق ومنازل المملكة العربية السعوديه
    اتصل بنا عبر جوال
    0555132104

    ReplyDelete
  23. يتواجد لدى شركة التفوق فريق محترف يقوم بخدمات متعدده لكشف تسربات المياه ولذلك نعد افضل شركات كشف تسربات المياه بكافه انحاء السعوديه
    واتصل بنا على جوال
    0550074416

    ReplyDelete
  24. نهدف فى شركة سوقنى الى الوصول بمواقع الويب الى صفحات البحث الاولى عبر جوجل وذلك عن طريق استضافه المواقع والعمل عليها
    اتصلوا بنا على تليفون
    002_01008745590

    ReplyDelete
  25. قطع الغيار الاصليه التى يتم بيعها فى منافذ بيع وايت ويل اضافه الى تقديم خدمات الصيانة المختلفه واسعارنا لا تقبل الجدال

    ReplyDelete
  26. Lowest costs with Unionaire maintenance center with original parts maintenance ..

    สูตรบาคาร่า
    gclub

    ReplyDelete
  27. Your blog is very useful for me,Thanks for your sharing.

    ทองดีฟันขาว

    ReplyDelete
  28. It seems I'm on the right track, I hope I can do well. The result was something I did and was doing to implement it.
    www.clickjogosclick.com

    ReplyDelete
  29. Call: 931OO96831, The best Industrial Automation training in delhi provided by DIAC. Industrial Automation Training Courses & Classes in Delhi deliver by DIAC Corporate trainers with Real time Projects.

    ReplyDelete
  30. يمكنك معرفة افضل ادوات التداول من خلال تصفحك لموقع افضل شركات الفوركس بالسعودية.

    ReplyDelete
  31. HMI Training | HMI Training in Noida | HMI Training in Delhi- 9818293887
    HMI training in noida offers by DIAC Corporate trainers with 100% placement assistance. The hmi training at an affordable price which is customised as per each candidate’s requirement of modules and content. Call @9310096830

    ReplyDelete
  32. If you want web designing course in Mumbai. Classboat provides you top web designing course in Mumbai with placement
    web designing course in Mumbai with placement

    ReplyDelete
  33. Thank you for this post. Want career in aviation. Classboat provides you
    best aviation courses in pune
    Best Aviation Courses in Pune

    ReplyDelete
  34. This is an awesome post. Really very informative and creative contents. These concept is a good way to enhance the knowledge. I am also sharing very important concept which is related to credit card. For more detail visit my blog PayPal's Credit Card Generator.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Thanks for provide great informatic and looking beautiful blog, really nice required information & the things i never imagined and i would request, wright more blog and blog post like that for us. Thanks you once agian

    special marriage act
    name add in birth certificate
    passport agent
    court marriage in delhi
    name change
    marriage registration
    birth certificate in gurgaon
    birth certificate in noida
    birth certificate in ghaziabad
    birth certificate in delhi

    ReplyDelete
  36. Thank you for excellent article.I enjoyed reading your blog!!
    Maral Gel Nga

    ReplyDelete
  37. Thank you for excellent article.I enjoyed reading your blog!!
    Giảm cân AB
    Habelric
    Maral Gel

    ReplyDelete

  38. Thank you for excellent article.I enjoyed reading your blog!!
    Rizin
    Bổ thận Rizin
    Maral Gel

    ReplyDelete
  39. Thank you for excellent article.I enjoyed reading your blog!!
    Oxy Detox sản phẩm xương khớp số 1 USA

    ReplyDelete
  40. To Find Tutors and Coaching online - Shutterupp is India’s largest platform offering one stop solution for all your local education lets find courses near you and boost your career related searches vand also Discover best coaching institutes in india. Explore the right path for your career.

    ReplyDelete
  41. Sản phẩm hỗ trợ điều trị tiểu đườngDiagood

    ReplyDelete
  42. Thanks for sharing your knowledge with us if you want to get more knowledge about the books visit our website

    ReplyDelete
  43. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  44. DIAC providing Summer training in PLC SCADA, Robotics, Embedded Systems and registration started few seats are left. So, what are you waiting for book your seat @ +91-99534-89987, +91-97112-87737.

    ReplyDelete
  45. Thanks for your personal marvelous posting! I quite enjoyed reading it,you could be a great author. Minecraft Skins

    ReplyDelete
  46. When some one searches for his vital thing,
    thus he/she needs to be available that in detail, thus that thing is maintained over here.
    경마
    온라인경마

    ReplyDelete

  47. Faye Chrisley :- Faye Chrisley is an American reality TV star. She is well-known for playing Nanny in the American TV series Chrisley Knows Best.

    Christi Pirro :- Christi Pirro is a lawyer and a law clerk. She is well-known as Jeanine Pirro’s daughter. Jeannie, her mother, is a TV broadcaster and writer.


    Pokimane :- Pokimane is a famous Canadian twitch streamer and YouTuber. However, she is famous for her streaming on games. So, she mostly played two games

    ReplyDelete
  48. Very nice post and blog, I found it very explanatory and informative, thank you very much for sharing your knowledge and wisdom with us.

    Hiltonbet
    Hiltonbet
    Meritking
    Meritking

    ReplyDelete
  49. Thanks for an interesting blog. What else may I get that sort of info written in such a perfect approach? I have an undertaking that I am just now operating on, and I have been on the lookout for such info 먹튀검증 It's amazing. I want to learn your writing skills. In fact, I also have a website. If you are okay, please visit once and leave your opinion. Thank you.


    ReplyDelete
  50. Congratulations on your article, it was very helpful and successful. 085f6e28fb46729bb62b4d0cb66f8fc5
    website kurma
    numara onay
    website kurma

    ReplyDelete
  51. Thank you for your explanation, very good content. 1db8710cf860f9931088fbdaf6b3c50b
    define dedektörü

    ReplyDelete