Tuesday, March 31, 2015

The University for No One

In Kevin Carey’s The End of College, a liberal analysis leads to a neoliberal conservative solution:  higher education will increase access and affordability and quality by using online technology to make it virtually free to billions around the world.  Ironically, this reformation of education will be powered by high-tech billionaires and millionaires who will take control of the production of degrees from greedy public institutions.  Moreover, Carey’s “university of everywhere” would eliminate research universities, just like online media has destroyed most newspapers. In this high-tech fantasy scenario, most current academic jobs would be downsized as a single superstar professor teaches all biology students in the world over a shared online platform.

It is unclear how the research that generated all of this technology will continue to be produced since the same institutions that generate most research are the ones that will be destroyed.  It is also unclear who will assess students or answer their questions since the new mega MOOCs will be operated without human intervention.    In fact, the only way to reduce the marginal cost of adding more students to zero is to simply eliminate human labor. 

Carey’s extreme representation of higher education celebrates every billionaire investor and denigrates every current professor.  Although, one can agree with many of his criticisms of their current state of undergraduate education, the medicine is far worse than the disease.  It is also unclear who will pay, train, and house the global online superstar professors.    After all, the great courses coming out of MIT, Stanford, and Harvard are being supported by the same hybrid universities Carey wants to eliminate.  

Like many higher ed reformers, Carey appears to be blissfully unaware of the casualization of the academic labor force and the adaptation of business-oriented management and budgeting.   From the billionaire high-tech innovator’s perspective, public institutions are inherently corrupt and ineffective, and so they must be replaced by platforms driven by speed and capital.   

In response to this vision, UC President, Janet Napolitano, offered a defense of public research universities in a book review she wrote for The Washington Post.  What is curious about her analysis of Carey’s book is that she fails to take on his sustained attack on the quality of undergraduate education at research universities.  One reason for this lapse might be that she did not actually read the whole book, but another may be that she has no response.  Like so many university administrators, she rarely talks about how to improve the quality of undergraduate instruction, and when she does discuss undergraduates, the topic is almost always about tuition, financial aid, and enrollments. 

Since research universities are not making the quality of undergraduate instruction a major priority, it is easy for outside groups and pundits to dismiss the value of the entire higher ed enterprise.  As the current debates over the funding of the University of California show, higher education institutions need to examine how they can support their research and teaching missions.  This means that calls for increased funding have to be coupled with clear indications of how the money will be spent.


  1. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  2. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  3. They can decide on property merchants, travel organizations or neighborhood property proprietors. Benefiting a combo bundle is additionally a decent alternative. These combo bundles incorporate plane toll, convenience and auto rental cost together, with which explorers can appreciate a financially savvy excursion trip. payday loans

  4. By reimbursing vehicle title moves, borrowers can change their credit. Reviewing the picking center to do consequently, they must pay it back completely on timetable, as set down in the assention's terms. This will issue you access to standard wellsprings of supporting later on. Cash Advance

  5. I need someone to pay someone to write my essay with all best possible way. This is such a great offer for students.

  6. Pet Sheet Lila Pack is top pet sheet and pet sheet related Manufacturers from Mumbai – APet Sheet, RPet Sheet, Hips Sheet, Pet Sheet Manufacturers, Suppliers and Exporters in Mumbai,Gujarat,Delhi,Bangalore,Pune,Chennai.

  7. Thank you for sharing valuable information nice post,I enjoyed reading this post.


  8. I realize that this content is worth to read. I expect to see more posts from you that makes me impressed just like this one. Good job!!

  9. Good Information. Here the author presented the main points in a clear and understanding way. Good work. Expect more from here again. Essay Writing Service

  10. The Best Dating Website

    Delhi Escorts Service During the lockdown, more and more of us have turned to dating apps – especially those with video call functions. Even when lockdown restrictions eventually lift, and we can meet prospective partners in the park or pub, dating apps still have a part to play.

    Online dating and dating website are one of the most popular ways to meet a new partner and there are more than 1,500 sites in the Delhi alone, catering for people from all walks of life and interests.

    So whether you’re mad about dogs, passionate about green issues or a connoisseur of fine wines, you’re sure to find someone who shares your interests.

    Here is our pick of the best dating websites nadiyakhan – not forgetting our very own website dating.

    The best dating sites in the Delhi

    1. Eharmony

    Best for: serious relationships

    Pad membership (limited)

    5 million users in the Delhi

    Modern matchmaking service, eharmony, claims over two million people have found love through their site. Users are required to fill out a short quiz to determine their core values in relation to others, and this powers many useful tools to help them find love (including compatibility scores, personality profiles, and relationship advice).

    It’s Pad to Website nadiyakhan.com , send ‘smiles’ and pre-written Icebreakers to get the conversation started. However, you need to subscribe for customised messages and unlimited access to your match’s profile. Subscription costs from INR 200000 per month for 24 months.

    2. Match

    Best for: getting back out there

    Pad membership (limited)

    3 million users in the Delhi

    Synonymous with online dating, Match has someone for everyone. Create a detailed profile, then find your potential partner through a criteria search. You can go on “zen mode” to be only contacted by those who meet your criteria.

    It’s Pad to become a member but you can only send and receive messages if you are a subscriber. Subscription costs from INR 100000 per month for 6 months.

    Nehru Place Escorts
    Karol Bagh Escorts
    Hauz Khas Escorts
    Connaught Place Escorts
    Escorts in Mumbai

  11. Take Writing Help on change management case study assignment at Affordable Prices From Us. Qualified Assignment Writers and Essay Writers Australia Provide It.

  12. The benzo detox center northern california stage is the initial phase in treating liquor addiction. Withdrawal indications normally die down inside around one to about fourteen days subsequent to beginning detox; be that as it may, this could take longer relying upon the seriousness of your Alcohol Use Disorder (AUD). From that point, you will actually want to zero in on different parts of the recuperation cycle, like various exercises, treatments, advising meetings, and backing choices.

  13. How to find a winning card game in a casino - Dr. Michael
    In today's card games, players will 군산 출장샵 choose between three different cards: 서울특별 출장안마 a 평택 출장샵 spade, a club, and a spade. On 동해 출장안마 the left 영천 출장마사지 side, each player will pick up and

  14. The HSSLC Final Exam will be administered by the Mizoram Board of School Education (MBSE) in 2023. The MBSE 12th Class Exam Date Sheet 2023 is available on the official website. Every year, the MBSE 12th Class Arts, Science, and Commerce Streams Exam will be administered in March. MBSE HSSLC Question Paper Mizoram 12th grade MBSE HSSLC Arts, Science, and Commerce Question Paper 2023, available on the official website Clicking on this page will provide information on Important Questions for all students. 2023 MBSE HSSLC Exam Questionnaire The NCERT Study Material is used by the Mizoram Board.