Tuesday, September 2, 2014

The Future of College Degrees and Jobs in California

The recent move to allow certain community colleges to produce bachelor degrees was in part driven by the argument that by the year 2025, the California economy will need an additional one million workers with BAs.  The research behind this claim appears to come primarily from the Public Policy Institute of California’s (PPIC) report, “Meeting California’s Need for College Graduates.” In this study, we are told that “Two strong forces are already at work in constraining California’s gradually increasing share of college graduates in the working population: the retirement of the large and relatively well-educated baby-boom cohort—adults born between 1946 and 1964—which will occur over the next 20 years, and demographic shifts toward groups that have historically low rates of college attendance and graduation.” The first half of the argument is a purely demographic projection of the future production of workers with bachelor degrees, and it makes the important point that we are now seeing a generation of people with a relatively high level of degree attainment replaced by a new generation, which suffers from a decrease in degree attainment. 

One of the driving forces behind this generational shift is the constant state defunding of higher education in California.  There is also a growing divide between the older, whiter workers who have college degrees and the younger, non-white workers who have been victims of several economic downturns and discriminatory educational practices.  The PPIC reports that “In 2006, California ranked 23rd among states in its share of 25- to 34-year- olds holding at least a bachelor’s degree, down from eighth position in 1960. California colleges and universities,
both public and private, award relatively few baccalaureates, given the size of the state’s youth population: California ranked 43rd among states in the ratio of bachelor’s degrees awarded in 2006 to high school diplomas awarded five years earlier.” In what we can call the “Fall of the Master Plan,” California has moved from being one of the most educated states to being one of the least. 
According to the PPIC, one of the results of this fall is the following: “we project the size of the education skills gap in 2025 and identify scenarios that could help close the gap. If current trends persist, California will have one million fewer college graduates than it needs in 2025—only 35 percent of working-age adults will have a college degree in an economy that would otherwise require 41 percent of workers to have a college degree.” One big question is how do these researchers know what jobs will require workers with bachelor degrees, and here is where things get very murky.  The PPIC makes the following claim: “Over the past 26 years, the share of college graduates in the state’s workforce has increased from 25 percent to 34 percent (Reed, 2008), but projections suggest that the state’s workforce demands will continue to increase and that 41 percent of jobs in 2025 will require a college degree.” The first thing to point out is that a college degree is here interpreted as a bachelor degree and not an associate degree, and so the entire realm of the community colleges is excluded.  The other major issue is the meaning of the phrase “jobs that require a college degree.”
It turns out that there are two main ways of interpreting the meaning of jobs that require a college degree.  Some labor economists use this phrase to describe jobs that are currently being held with people with certain degrees and other economists use the same phrase to indicate jobs that traditionally require a particular degree.  The difference between these two interpretations is huge and plays a major role in determining our educational and employment practices and policies.
The PPIC tries to finesse these opposing definitions of jobs requiring degrees in the following way: “For example, from 1990 to 2006, the share of workers with a college degree increased from 25 to 34 percent; our projections indicate that this trend will continue at about the same pace, so that by 2025, 41 percent of workers will need to hold a college degree if the workforce is to meet the demands of the California economy. This projected increase will occur partly as the state’s economy shifts to occupations and industries that require more highly educated workers but also as employers demand more highly educated workers within industries and occupations (Reed, 2008).” So we do not know if the need for more people with bachelor degrees is being driven by the supply of more high-skilled jobs or by the employer demand for more degrees in occupations that do not traditionally require degrees.
To answer this question, we must go to the cited source, Deborah Reed’s “Will There Be Enough College Graduates.” The first big move that Reed makes is to distinguish between her method for defining jobs that require degrees from the Bureau of Labor Statistics: “Our projections of demand for college-educated workers lead to very different conclusions than do estimates of employer needs derived from employer “education and training requirements” from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS). According to BLS estimates of employer education requirements by occupation, the share of college-educated workers needed in the California economy in 2025 would be only 27 percent. The two measures are conceptually different. The BLS-based approach considers whether employers need college-educated workers to staff positions. Our measure considers whether employers are choosing workers with bachelor’s degrees.”  What Reed stresses is that what matters is not which degrees are required to do the job but which degrees employers can demand.  In other words, in a buyer’s market, employers can pick and choose whom they want to hire, and they often hire people with the higher degrees.
One of the effects of this labor system is that occupations with the highest level of growth and demand for people with bachelor degrees turns out to be janitors, cleaners, carpenters, waiters, office clerks, bookkeepers, retail sales people, manufacturers, and secretaries. Reed argues that this is not a case of over-trained or over-educated workers because employers are paying more for workers with bachelor degrees, and rational employers would only do this if they knew they were getting their money’s worth.  In fact, in these occupations, which once did not require a college degree, we find that employers are willing to pay workers much more money if they have a college degree. 
What Reed does not reveal is how much of the difference in pay between workers doing the same jobs but with different degrees is due to the depression of wages for people without college degrees.  According to a Federal Reserve study, in 1980, a worker with a BA degree or higher averaged $52,000 a year (in 2008 dollars), while the same group’s average in 2008 was $56,000.  In contrast, the average worker with only a high school degree made $45,000 in 1980, and in 2008 made $32,000.  So if the college premium in 2008 was $20,000, the part due to the reduction of wages for the person without a college degree was $13,000 or 65%.  What we are seeing then on both a state and national level is that employers are able to demand degrees from workers for jobs that do not traditionally require college degrees and the effect is to increase the wages for some workers with degrees but also decrease the wages for workers without degrees.
The point here is not that we do not need to increase state funding to produce more people with college degrees; rather we have to find a way to both increase the number of good middle-class jobs as we decrease the financial cost of individuals pursuing degrees.  We also have to question the notion that degrees produce jobs, and the only reason to fund public higher education is to increase an individual’s earning power. Educational policy does not replace employment policy, and both should work together.    


  1. I do not believe it. Students are tapped out and are not going to college like they used to. Enrollments at many colleges are down this fall and this trend will continue. I am hearing stories of students refusing to buy books. I believe the current "college industrial complex" will collapse and be replaced with online forms of learning that are more cost effective in terms of getting and education that can easily be monetized via a job or entrepreneurship. Author “The Art of Debt Guerrilla Warfare, how to beat debt collectors when your back is the against the wall”

  2. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  3. http://www.shopbestgoods.com/

  4. The construct has been designed to twin as a general short remedy for your current payday loans economical desires. A bankruptcy continued adult vegas quantity will get paid, you then include sort of decisions in relevance ways that to possess a bent to repay.

  5. One can avail these thus on meet with current, pressing demands and is given blast to repay them. As these sorts of finances involve high amounts of money, the recipient ought to give the capitalist slightly of property as security payday loans that's in associate passing position to be taken into possession if the recipient is unable to repay among the granted time.

  6. They're out there day and night, seven days every week, and in several cases the method is thus absolutely machine-controlled that loans area unit granted while not the recipient ever having to talk to a different person. when candidates have established a documentation of with success paying off amount loans, some lenders solely need candidates to text the number of the required loan, and
    payday loans richmond also the term of the loan desired, and also the cash is instantly created out there.

  7. This is a great article. It gave me a lot of useful information. thank you very much.
    juegoskizi | juegos kizi | juegos de kizi

  8. This is called false showcasing. Much the same as the wording "false advancing" the dominant part of these associations never express every bit of relevant information about their association. They may contract outsourced editorialists and authors to form their substance.title loan jackson-MS

  9. In the event that you have a vehicles, you can set up the title up as security and get an improvement considering the estimation of the auto. A substantial sample, different affiliations which offer these sorts of advances will permit you to get up to 50% of the estimation of your auto.

  10. Payday advances and money credits, you can utilize the money for the credit to be connected inside of 24 hours of support of advance extra them from the long holding up time borrower. payday loans chicago

  11. So it is alright to send messages through. Utilization hues. Arranging is regularly lavish. A man's don't own the cash to spend, attempt blooms. There's no compelling reason to burn through cash on uncommon, intriguing plants.online cash advance in fresno ca

  12. After you have acquired moment cash, you can undoubtedly satisfy your monetary needs. Contingent on your critical money necessities, you can get online and acquire moment cash from banks. The credit sum may be little yet is helpful to determine unforeseen money related costs which incorporate home rentals, home change, charge card duty installment, phone bills, and other little monetary costs. Payday Loans

  13. From now on, a borrower must be watchful before settling on a completed up choice in any money related condition, particularly when their most vital ticket ownership is being utilized as confirmation. Cash Advance San-diego

  14. Spare cash on your new or existing vehicle credit. New or utilized vehicles, cruisers or delight make. Look over various banks and credit unions in your general vicinity. Shoppers can spare a lot of cash over customary merchant financing. auto title loans

  15. A couple banks will in like manner consider occupation status and wage as parts when choosing support for a vehicle title advance. Nevertheless, all that you have to look for a title development is affirmation that you have your vehicle, and there is not a past lien on your title. Cash Advance

  16. I besides oblige you to value that the clear it letter can be utilized for any kind of commitment collecting and not simply payday credits. It is key to know your rights and you can discover them out online at the affiliation exchange commission's page where you can get two or three answers concerning the sensible commitment get-together act. You will see what banks can and can't do concerning the social event of your commitments and how to stop truly made and bothering conduct. www.aaa1autotitleloans.com/chicago


  17. With a specific completed target to be possessed all the necessary qualities for a payday credit you must be more than 18 years of age and in work with a take home wage of at any rate £750 reliably. You should also have a record with a liberal charge card.
    Payday Loans San-diego

  18. The credit must be paid off in a singular part. If the borrower is not planned to pay title credits toward the term's end, then there's sometimes a choice decision. He or she can "move over" the change, which joins taking out another automobile title credit in light of your vehicle's title. Cash Advance

  19. If there are specific choices for you to get a credit with shocking credit, watch that you consider those as of now whether a vehicle title development is the best answer beginning as of right now. Other fast cash sort advances consolidate; unsecured individual credits, payday progress credits, guaranteed payday pushes, enthusiastic business credits and secured individual credit propels. www.usacheckcashingstore.com/san-diego

  20. Amidst the advancement set up, the title credit alliance gathering recreation movement. Once more, all affiliations are unmistakable. A few affiliations utilize high loan fees, and changing affiliations utilize low financing costs. Unmistakably no one would oblige high financing costs, yet the credit affiliations that may utilize these high loan fees, likely in like way give moreover stimulating qualities to the borrowers. What are the standard qualities? auto title loans chicago

  21. Here's my recommendation today; Study the profitable individuals and comprehend which of them is most like you. In the event that you are most like the triumphs who are tangled and inquired... by then don't waver to trap things and walk around achievement. Payday Loans

  22. This comment has been removed by the author.

  23. The ideas beyond those features almost stating the true values which are considered to be important for any of the writer to develop within himself. affordable writing services

  24. The principle necessity here is for you to have a demonstrate title in your innocence. Without that, the credit can be an issue. In any case, having a reasonable title on your auto is exceptionally ordinary and each one who possesses an auto has it no doubt. cash advance costa-mesa

  25. This created a between dependence of commercial enterprises. Every gathering of individuals spend significant time in one territory had a requirement for products or administrations gave by another.check cashing

  26. Part of being the adroit shopper is paying consideration on the items that you are acquiring. Regularly, sick significance auto rental organizations will attempt to offer you rental protection and GPS gadgets that you don't generally require.Check Cashing Costa-mesa

  27. Single installment Loan: This includes installment of the whole measure of cash taken as an advance, alongside the financing costs, at a specific date later on. check cashing

  28. It is about the extent of your thumb. It records video and sound and obviously it likewise plays mp3s. This minor gadget can be set anyplace in your vehicles and nobody could ever see that you have mystery camera inside your auto.Payday Loans Oceanside

  29. Queste alternative a base di erbe forniscono anche diversi ingredienti nutrizionali utile come proteine, ferro, fosforo, calcio, e danno un insieme con un effetto afrodisiaco intenso. curare l'impotenza a 20 anni

  30. Almeno il tempo è migliorato in Inghilterra dalle visioni che avevamo visto in TV. In realtà è oggi più caldo che in Spagna, quindi abbiamo sicuramente portato il bel tempo con noi! il curriculum perfetto studenti