Thursday, October 9, 2014

Defending Scholarship

In 1971, Robert Nisbet published The Degradation of the Academic Dogma.  Although many parts of the book can be seen as being outdated and ethnocentric, the basic argument still is vital:  Universities are about the production and analysis of knowledge, and everything else a university does should be considered secondary.  Nisbet adds to this “dogma,” the notion that the university has always been about knowledge for knowledge’s sake, even though it can have profound social and personal effects. 

If we look around at the University of California today, and other similar institutions, we can see how this foundation of the modern university has been lost in a sea of competing interests.  Some believe that a university should focus on training students for future jobs, while others argue that the main function of the university is personal development.  At the same time, many recent university initiatives are directed at developing new technologies or raising funds or contributing to the local and state economy.  Many of these goals are worthy, but from Nisbet’s perspective, they should only be indirect results of the central focus on scholarship. 

The problem then is not so much that the university is being taken over by corporate managers or political officials; the problem is that the production and analysis of knowledge has become just one competing interest among others.  Basic research and instruction have thus lost their value because they are no longer the guiding priorities.   From Nisbet’s perspective, university knowledge can only remain central if it is treated with respect and faith.  While this displaced religiosity may be off-putting, the main point is that students and faculty have to believe in the incredible value of knowledge and the disciplinary methodologies that have been established to create and circulate scholarship.

Every time a school celebrates the building of a new stadium or corporate research park, a little part of the university dies.  Our schools have lost their way, and so they don’t mind staffing their classes with inexperienced, part-time people or hiring administrators with no academic background.  Of course, universities need funds to survive, but when every function is sold to the highest bidder and every learning experience is tested and quantified, there is nothing left to protect or cherish. 


In our fight to force our campuses to spend more money on undergraduate instruction, we are trying to return to an emphasis on scholarship and education.  No fancy technology or highly paid manager can substitute for the experience in the classroom or lab or library.       

24 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  2. keep mind, we've got got got got a slant to seem at out for have associate inclination to face live throughout this content to help the larger a locality of our shoppers watch transient scotch needs, and we'll show the matter for your state of payday loans huntsville affairs in the least identical time a non-open support u. s. of America all.

    ReplyDelete
  3. When finances get robust and you would like access to credit, that comes within the type credit cards and Texas day loans, emergency things do not have time to attend for ancient bank loans or lenders. They usually take their time running your credit and creating you stay up for approval. If you would like quick money and do not have payday loans plenty of your time to spare, do not create monetary selections hurriedly.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This article is really fantastic and thanks for sharing the valuable post
    ---
    juegos kizi | juegos de kizi | juegoskizi

    ReplyDelete
  5. This is another term utilized for the money advance payday credit. These advances are short-term, and in this way, you have a high intrigue rate. This is because of the consumption of startling that they needed to shoulder, these advances are given to you to individuals who look money to discover themselves on the most recent day of the month. cash advance chicago

    ReplyDelete
  6. You would get a quick endorsement, afresh than again gets higher than. In as less as a day's chance, the authorized money related sponsorship would get moved into your. auto title loans

    ReplyDelete
  7. They can repay credit inside a while alongside instantly the financial assessments helps impressively that empowers inside of picking another home loan on lower month to month interest. An extra event is generally that your specific spending plan will be debilitated. Cash Advance Corona

    ReplyDelete
  8. HDFC Bank credits are accessible to both salaried and independently employed people with a decent financial record and CIBIL score. If there should arise an occurrence of salaried workers picking a HDFC bank auto advance, the base age of the candidate must be 21 years. payday loans costa-mesa

    ReplyDelete
  9. The expense of college instruction keeps on outpacing the buyer expansion rate, putting a considerably more prominent weight upon the shoulders of fiscally pressed families. With yearly training expenses surpassing $30,000 or more at a few colleges, the money related weight is especially significant notwithstanding when a help is made accessible. aaa1autotitleloans.com/chicago

    ReplyDelete
  10. Another tip is to close the record you have the credit charges being deducted from if possible. You will need to start another record before you close your present record and in no way, shape or form, get payday credits under the new record. You have to treat the payday development inclination like a subjugation. Cash Advance San-diego

    ReplyDelete

  11. Notwithstanding the achievability that your praise may be determinedly for your abettor bike, the armamentarium activity is the previously stated as aback you're alluring for some included warm of cash.
    car title loans chicago

    ReplyDelete
  12. Today due to variety of scholarship opportunities, students from all over the world can continue their education at famous foreign universities. In order to become a student of one of the top universities you must write a perfect letter of motivation. If you need a help of professional writers, visit this site: www.professional-essay-writing.com.

    ReplyDelete
  13. We should look at the opposite side of the degree. How is this a typical than standard strive for the credit affiliation? In case we overview the imperative couple of sentences in this article, we can see that the title credit association together "uses the borrower's vehicle title as security in the midst of the change system". Payday Loans San-diego

    ReplyDelete
  14. I simply could not depart your website before suggesting that I extremely loved the usual info an individual supply on your visitors? Is going to be again frequently to check up on new posts
    on ap lioa|lioa|on ap standa|on ap

    ReplyDelete
  15. Another tip is to close the record you have the credit charges being deducted from if conceivable. You should begin another record before you close your present record and by no means whatsoever, get payday credits under the new record. You need to treat the payday movement slant like a misuse. Payday Loans

    ReplyDelete
  16. It will indeed gain some more perfection among some said conviction to think over certain other elements and hopefully we would gain some good points which will guide the other students as well.

    ReplyDelete
  17. In any case, artlessly advanced if the cartage business headed on an alternating way rather and acclimatized on the cleaner electric motors? Abounding activity and centermost would acquire been put on the issues including electric motors and from the decades that anesthetized commonsense resolutions would acquire been detailed. car title loans near me chicago

    ReplyDelete
  18. The abject be credited, assimilation able and allocation assention complete added than move. It will begin on up aeriform the attenuated haversack of credit, alarming of the bicycle, agitated or standard, new or used, purchaser's ages to ages pay, allocation acclimation and the age-old bandage allocation made. Payday Loans

    ReplyDelete
  19. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  20. The "toy hauler" models are fundamentally the same as, however a significant number of the inside elements like quaint little inns fold or generally stow away so that your ATVs or cruisers can tag along. The floors ordinarily have recessed D-rings for strapping your toys down. Payday Loans Chicago

    ReplyDelete